3 min read
What can the next generation of disruptive technologies learn from graphene? That was the question at the heart of our recent panel discussion and networking event at our London office, which brought together experts from across the advanced materials ecosystem to consider the lessons graphene can offer the next generation of disruptive technologies.
The discussion was moderated by James Baker, founder of Baker Graphene, alongside Victoria Mataczynski, co-founder of Nanoloom, Jonathan Bean, CEO and co-founder of MatNex, and Arielle Seconde-Kynnersley, investor at IP Group.
Together, they explored the journey from material to market, the challenges of scaling advanced materials businesses in the UK, the growing role of AI and what investors are looking for from the next generation of materials technologies.
One message came through particularly strongly: remarkable science is not, in itself, a value proposition.
Graphene attracted enormous attention because of its exceptional properties. But customers are rarely looking for graphene, or indeed any particular advanced material. Instead, they have problems they need to solve: making something lighter, stronger, more conductive, more resilient or easier to manufacture.
That distinction has important consequences. Starting with a new material and searching for somewhere to use it is very different from identifying a valuable problem and asking whether a new material provides the answer.
The conversation also turned to the UK's strength in materials science and R&D, and the more difficult question of what happens when businesses need to scale.
Energy costs, access to skilled labour, planning and policy constraints and access to funding beyond the R&D stage were among the challenges raised by the panel.
This led to a wider discussion about resilience. In areas such as critical minerals and defence, the best-performing material may not always be the most strategically valuable. Access to a technology that performs well enough but can be manufactured and supplied securely may, in some circumstances, be more important than pursuing technical perfection.
Perhaps inevitably, AI also entered the conversation.
Rather than focusing solely on AI's potential to discover new materials, the discussion considered the opportunities much closer to manufacturing: understanding structure-property relationships, learning from process data, optimising production conditions and supporting scale-up.
Nanoloom, for example, is already collecting data throughout its manufacturing process with those opportunities in mind.
One particularly interesting takeaway was that AI's biggest impact on advanced materials may prove to be not simply what we discover, but how successfully we learn to make it.
Despite the extraordinary levels of investment currently flowing towards AI, the panel was relatively optimistic about the prospects for advanced materials.
The underlying questions remain familiar: does the technology solve an important problem, is there a customer for the resulting product and can the company build a viable business around it?
Graphene itself provided an interesting example. It is increasingly finding its way into commercial products without necessarily being the headline. Rather than a technology looking for an application, it is becoming another tool available to product designers.
That quieter form of adoption may ultimately be a better indication of commercial maturity than the level of attention surrounding a technology.
And, given that the discussion took place in our offices, intellectual property inevitably entered the conversation too, prompting some refreshingly frank discussion about patents, costs and the role of patent attorneys in supporting innovative businesses.
Start with the problem, not the material; exceptional properties do not automatically create commercial value. Successful materials businesses need to understand the problem their customers are trying to solve and demonstrate why their technology provides a better answer.
Scaling matters as much as discovery: The UK has considerable strengths in materials science and R&D, but capturing the full value of those innovations also requires manufacturing capability, skills, investment and infrastructure.
Resilience can change what “best” means: Technical performance is not the only consideration. Secure access to materials, manufacturing and supply chains can make a “good enough” solution strategically more valuable than a technically superior alternative.
AI could transform how materials are manufactured: Materials discovery is only part of the opportunity. Process data, optimisation and scale-up could prove equally important applications for AI.
Commercial maturity can be quiet: Graphene appearing in products without being the headline may be a sign of progress rather than declining interest.
Ultimately, successful materials need to solve problems rather than sell themselves on novelty alone.
We finished by asking the panel what excites them about the future of materials. There was optimism around the prospect of advanced materials attracting renewed attention and investment, but also a more fundamental point: there are still many exciting materials waiting to be discovered.
Perhaps, then, one of the most important lessons from graphene is that discovery is only the beginning. The harder challenge is building the manufacturing capability, investment, supply chains and customer demand needed to translate scientific promise into technologies that people actually use.
The conversation continued well beyond the panel discussion, with plenty more debate and networking over drinks afterwards.
We would like to thank James, Victoria, Jonathan and Arielle for sharing their perspectives, and everyone who joined us for such an engaging and thought provoking evening.

Matthew is a Partner and Patent Attorney at Mewburn Ellis. Working primarily in the chemical and materials science fields, he has significant experience of the intricacies of the EPO. Matthew advises and assists clients with all stages of drafting, prosecution, opposition and appeal before the EPO. Many of his clients are Japanese and Chinese businesses that are seeking European patent protection. These include multinational corporations in the fields of high-performance ceramics and carbon fibre technologies, as well as pharmaceutical and cosmetic companies. Matthew also works with several research institutions and university technology transfer departments across Europe.
Email: matthew.smith@mewburn.com
Stay up to date with our latest thinking.