Spotlight on Software

IP protection for software. It’s complicated

As we move deeper into the fourth industrial revolution, software is becoming ever more inextricably linked to how we live and work. With advances in technologies such as cloud computing, the internet of things, machine learning, block chain and quantum computing, new developments in software are continuing to change the world we live in at a rapid pace.

Although there are many companies whose sole focus is software development, there are a growing numbers of companies who are developing new software as part of a wider technological offering. Consequently, it is growing increasingly common for large software developers to see themselves as technology companies, rather than as software companies.

Patent protection, when available, can be an extremely useful tool for securing strong protection for software-related developments. However, patent protection for software is not always possible, owing in part to software sitting in a grey area of what can and cannot be patented. In some cases, forms of IP other than patents (e.g. copyright) may be a more effective route for protecting software.

In view of the complicated legal framework that exists around software inventions, a company looking to secure protection for new software-related developments needs sound advice to if they are to get to an IP position that suits their needs. Here at Mewburn Ellis, we have the technical and legal expertise needed to help our clients achieve this.

Read our Software Blogs

The major players in the SEP landscape in Europe

Next in our series of blogs, we have investigated the major players in the SEP landscape in Europe.

How does declaring a patent or application as “essential to a standard” affect the pre-grant experience of an application? – Part 3

This article continues our series of blogs investigating whether or not declaring your patent or application as “essential to a standard” influences the outcome of that patent or application in ...

Emotional Perception AI v UKIPO: Is this the dawning of a new era for AI-related inventions at the UKIPO?

On 21 November 2023, Mann J handed down his judgment on Emotional Perception AI Ltd v Comptroller-General of Patents, Designs, and Trade Marks [2023] EWHC 2948 (Ch)i, relating to the patentability of ...

IP Protection for software-based products- An Introduction for SMEs

We are excited to launch our new software resource booklet — 'IP Protection for software-based products - An Introduction for SMEs'.

How does declaring a patent or application as “essential to a standard” affect the pre-grant experience of an application?

This article is the latest in a series of blogs exploring whether declaring your patent or application as “essential to a standard” influences the outcome of that patent or application in Europe.

Gene sequencing accelerates with custom hardware

The cost to sequence a genome continues to drop exponentially. Over the past 20 years, the cost to sequence a human genome has dropped from the estimated $3 billion of the Human Genome Project, to a ...

IP Protection for software-based products - An Introduction for SMEs

Campaign Resource Booklet

Led by James Leach, this booklet explores the different types of IP protection available for software-based products and provide practical guidance on how these different forms of IP can be used to provide meaningful protection. We also look at how to go about developing an IP strategy that fits with your company’s business model and goals.

Patenting Software in Europe – What you Really Need to Consider

When about it comes to securing IP protection for software, there is a common misconception that software isn’t patentable. In fact, it is possible in certain circumstances to obtain European patent protection for novel software, provided it can be shown that the software solves a “technical problem” in a non-obvious manner.

The law in this area is complex (we’ve written an in-depth study here), and there is ultimately no substitute for talking with us about your business needs, but here are five key things you need to think about if you are thinking about seeking patent protection for some newly developed software:

Consider what is new about what the software is doing, and consider whether that new bit is “technical” or “non-technical” in nature

Even if the software is based on an original idea, you will struggle for patent protection in Europe if that underlying idea relates to a non-technical process.

If you’re struggling to determine what might be viewed as “technical”, then seek help!

European patent offices have always resisted providing clear guidance on what is/isn’t “technical”, so this is a grey area. We can help!

If the invention is based on a business/administrative idea, think twice

It’s not impossible to get patent protection in the context of a business/administrative process, but it’s rare, so you should seek advice before proceeding. Again, we can help!

Consider whether copyright protection might suffice

Copyright will stop others from copying your source code, without the significant expense associated with the patenting process. There are limitations to copyright protection, but it’s worth considering whether this might enough for your purposes, especially if it’s not clear whether the underlying invention will be considered patent eligible in Europe.

Think carefully about jurisdictions

Not all patent offices handle software inventions in the same way. For example, the UK Intellectual Property Office (“UKIPO”) has a very restrictive approach to assessing the patentability of software inventions which is demonstrably out of step with the European Patent Office (“EPO”). Where best to seek protection for software can vary depending on the nature of the software that has been developed, and it is best to seek our advice on this.

Fixed-fee patent eligibility opinions on software patents

Patent applications for inventions relating to software can sometimes run into problematic patent eligibility objections at the EPO. By using our fixed-fee opinion service, it is possible to get a considered view on whether a proposed European patent filing will encounter such an objection, before incurring the significant costs associated with filing a European patent application.

Forward-looking: Software - The Years Ahead

The 2000s and 2010s saw an unprecedented amount of innovation and change within software. From social networking to cloud computing, from machine learning to blockchain, we have witnessed a number of significant developments that have changed the way we live, work and play. So how will the software ecosystem change over the 2020s and 2030s? If the past decade was anything to go by then making definitive predictions seems nigh impossible.

Here are some areas we will be watching closely as we head towards the 2030s:

New applications for AI and machine learning: With AI/machine learning tools now maturing, it will be interesting to see the new ways in which these tools find new uses in our everyday lives.

Quantum computing: As quantum computing technologies continue to progress, we look forward to seeing if new and useful applications can be found for this emerging technology. We are keeping a close eye on quantum computing developments, please see our Quantum spotlight page if you are interested in finding out more.

FinTech: The blockchain and cryptocurrencies have been agents of change which have already transformed the world of finance beyond recognition. We think more change is to come in the world of FinTech. It will be particularly interesting to see if cryptocurrencies progress to being used for everyday transactions, and whether any new applications can be found for the blockchain. We are keeping a close eye on FinTech developments

Encryption: Digital communications and transactions rely heavily on encryption, and with the emergence of technologies such as cryptocurrencies, this dependence continues to grow apace. In recent years, modern cryptography techniques have proved robust against attack, but could emerging technologies such as quantum computers expose vulnerabilities in modern encryption techniques? It will be interesting to see if encryption techniques can continue to evolve at a pace that keeps our data, communications and transactions secure.

Find out more about our expertise in this space.

Software Inventions: UKIPO and EPO approaches to patent eligibility

Special Report

It is well-known that it can be challenging to obtain patent protection for inventions relating to software in Europe. Indeed, it is common for software developers to assume that European patent protection is not available for their innovations

In this report we take a close look at whether the European Patent Office (“EPO”) and the UK Intellectual Property Office (“UKIPO”) handle software inventions differently. We also reveal some strategic insights that we think will be of benefit to companies seeking patent protection for software inventions in the UK and Europe.