Spotlight on

Engineering, Electronics and Software Oppositions

An opposition strategy can make or break a business. Whether you’re at the receiving end of an opposition, or are looking to clear the way for your own products or services, it’s important to get it right. Our Special Report 'EPO Opposition Trends in Engineering, Electronics and Software' provides fresh insights into this complex area.

The Mewburn Ellis team have a proven track record in opposition proceedings. We currently have in excess of 300 live patent oppositions at the EPO and have successfully defended and attacked hundreds over the years. We understand that successful oppositions require not only deep technical expertise and knowledge of the subject matter under scrutiny, but a forensic understanding of the evolving procedural aspects of the European Patent Office (EPO) process and timelines.

In autumn 2020, we analysed more than 8000 opposition cases filed at the EPO over the last 12 years, studying the timelines for hundreds of engineering, electronics and software oppositions. Using a tailored computer programme built by Camille Terfve, associate in our life sciences team, we were able to identify trends and answer key questions. Through this research we wanted to truly understand how oppositions are affected by procedural changes and the Covid-19 pandemic so we can advise our clients on the best opposition strategies to succeed.

As engineering, electronics and software cover a vast range of disciplines, we focused in on four sectors: Transport, Medical Devices, Telecommunications and Software. These sectors were chosen not only for their importance as measured by number of patent applications and number of oppositions, but also their significance in the wider economy. In the report we look at whether opposition outcomes are the same across different technology sectors and which players are the most active in oppositions.

Read our Opposition Blogs

Most opposed patents of 2023

Multiple sclerosis therapies are the subject of two of the most opposed patents of 2023. Novartis’ EP2959894 is notable from a patent attorney perspective not only because it’s the subject of 23 ...

Amended Rules of Procedure of the EPO Boards of Appeal are coming into force on 1 January 2024

The EPO Boards of Appeal have now published their amended Rules of Procedure and these will be effective from 1 January 2024.

EPO will accelerate oppositions when there are parallel UPC infringement or revocation proceedings

The EPO have announced in the November 2023 Official Journal that they will accelerate opposition proceedings when they are informed of infringement or revocation proceedings related to the same ...

Practical tips for EPO appeal proceedings under the new, stricter rules: 5 key takeaways from a recent EPO conference

In 2020 the EPO revised the rules that govern the procedure at the EPO Boards of Appeal. As we reported here, these new rules of procedure apply stricter standards regarding the admissibility of ...

Most opposed patents of 2022

As with CRISPR, patents directed to Nobel Prize-winning technologies are viewed as extremely valuable, at least judging by the number of parties seeking their revocation. The 2023 Nobel Prize for ...

Opposition and examination oral proceedings by videoconference (ViCo) now as standard

In response to the significant travel restrictions that were in place across Europe during the COVID-19 pandemic, the EPO allowed most of its legal hearings – oral proceedings – to be held by video ...

Answers to Key Questions

In 2019 Mewburn Ellis launched its first special report on EPO opposition trends. The report came at an important juncture, with procedural changes introduced by the EPO in 2016 to streamline the opposition process taking effect. The original research looked at oppositions in the life sciences.

Now, two years on, this new research focuses on engineering, electronics and software. We had several key questions we wanted to address when we commenced this new research. These were:

Is the EPO’s streamlining of the opposition process still impacting the timings of key stages in the opposition process?
Can we see effects of the disruption caused by the Covid-19 pandemic?
Are opposition outcomes the same across different technology sectors, or do they vary?
Who are the most opposed patentees?
Who are the most active opponents?

Special Report

EPO Opposition Trends in Engineering, Electronics and Software

In autumn 2020, we analysed more than 8000 opposition cases filed at the European Patent Office (EPO) over the last 12 years, studying the timelines for hundreds of engineering, electronics and software oppositions.

The research enabled us to see how oppositions have been affected by procedural changes at the European Patent Office and by the Covid-19 pandemic. With a focus on Transport, Medical Devices, Telecommunications and Software, the report also looks at how opposition outcomes vary across the four different technology sectors and which players are the most active.

Experts in Oppositions

Emma Graham, Partner and co-author of the report commented, “The EPO’s streamlining initiative has been a welcome boost for patentees, particularly for those in the technical space of computer implemented inventions (including software-related inventions), as the “Early Certainty” programme provides stronger legal and commercial certainty at an earlier stage.

“This is crucial for patentees in a rapidly evolving technical landscape as these inventions will typically have a shorter shelf life compared to other fields; if a patent is to be commercially valuable, it should be granted and any oppositions resolved before this shelf life is reached. Our research, which shows the acceleration of engineering, electronics and software oppositions over recent years, underlines the EPO’s streamlining initiative’s success.”

Stephen Gill, Partner and co-author of the report added: “When analysing data from the EPO, we were keen to look at exactly how the EPO streamlining initiative has impacted the overall opposition process since it was first introduced nearly five years ago, along with how the pandemic has disrupted procedures.

“It was encouraging to see how successfully and efficiently the EPO responded to the postponement of hearings in the early days of the pandemic by introducing video-conferencing for opposition division oral proceedings. This has allowed the opposition timeline to be maintained for many cases, and is something we expect the EPO to continue with long after the pandemic. It brings advantages for attorneys and applicants, and is also consistent with a wider “greener agenda."

Find out more about the EPO Opposition process in our law and practice guide. This information is available in Japanese, Chinese and Korean.

You can also find out more about our Opposition Services and why we're Europe's number one choice.

Mewburn Ellis

FORWARD MAGAZINE

Mewburn Ellis Forward is a biannual publication that celebrates the best of innovation and exploration. Through its pages we hope to inform and entertain, but also to encourage discussion about the most compelling developments taking place in the scientific and entrepreneurial world. Along the way, we’ll engage with the IP challenges that international organisations face every day.

Subscribe now